Using Diagrams to Build and Extend Student Understanding

Take a moment to think about the value of each expression below. 

\frac{1}{4}\times \frac{1}{3}

\frac{1}{4}\times \frac{2}{3}

\frac{2}{4}\times \frac{2}{3}

\frac{3}{4}\times \frac{2}{3}

What do you notice? How would you explain the things you notice?

If you are like us, or the students in Ms. Stark’s grade 5 classroom, you may have noticed many things. Things such as each expression has the same denominator, or the way in which the values increased as the problems progressed. When students notice these things, we often ask, ‘Why is that happening?” but it can be challenging to explain why beyond the procedure one followed. 

But fifth graders are brilliant. 

Grade 5 teacher Francesca Stark wrote an enthusiastic email after doing this number talk from IM K–5 Math with her students.

“We were interrupted by the fire drill,” she wrote. “But students were looking at the patterns of the products: \frac{1}{12} , \frac{2}{12} , \frac{4}{12} , \frac{6}{12} .” They wondered, “why an increase of \frac{1}{4} in the first factor of the last three problems made the product go up by \frac{2}{12}, but an increase of \frac{1}{3} in the second factor of the first and second problem only made the product increase by \frac{1}{12} .” She was thinking about ways to support students in discovering why this was happening.

This Number Talk comes after a series of lessons focusing on conceptual experiences with multiplying fractions. In prior lessons, students have found a fraction of a fraction, for example, “there was \frac{1}{4} of a pan of cornbread remaining, and Priya ate \frac{1}{5} of it.” and used diagrams to solve and represent their thinking.

Students developed their understanding as they noticed the denominators multiplied to find the number of small rectangles in a unit square and the numerators multiplied to find the number of shaded pieces.

These ideas were all built with a consistent representation: the area diagram. So when the fifth graders wanted to explore the why behind what they observed in the products of the number talk, they had a common visual language to use.

Students started by representing the first problem in the string, \frac{1}{4}\times \frac{1}{3} . Every student adeptly represented the product with a rectangle partitioned into fourths and thirds and shaded in a single small rectangle— \frac{1}{12} of the whole—to represent the product.

Next, students were asked to represent the other three problems. Some students decided to show each problem on a separate diagram, which allowed us to look for the difference between the four representations. Other students chose to show all four problems on a single diagram, using labels or colors to indicate the change from problem to problem.

This student decided to show her work on a single diagram. She modeled the first problem— \frac{1}{4}\times \frac{1}{3}=\frac{1}{12} —in green, and added on the additional \frac{1}{12} piece in blue to show how the diagram would need to change to show the second problem, \frac{1}{4}\times \frac{2}{3} . “Then, to change it to show \frac{2}{4}\times \frac{2}{3}, you’re only adding a fourth, but now each fourth has two pieces colored in, not one.” When pressed to explain further, she added, “I guess because it went up to \frac{2}{3} , so it’s 2 pieces out of 3 colored in every time.”

“For thirds, I shade another column. For fourths, I shade another row,” this student explained. “After the second problem, there’s two in a row, so that’s \frac{2}{12} .”

“I did the same thing,” another student said. “I kept adding rows with two across. If there were only 1 across it would be adding \frac{1}{12} , but there’s 2 for the \frac{2}{3} , so it’s \frac{2}{12} .”

The IM K–5 Math curriculum purposefully makes use of mathematical representations as a way for students to develop an understanding of concepts and procedures. In this particular case, the area diagram supported students in their reasoning and communication about how the change in factors impacted the products as they multiplied fractions. Students took ownership of this mathematical representation to push their thinking in new directions.

All of these students are still wrestling with the underlying mathematics, and figuring out how to communicate ideas clearly. The diagram supports this work. It gives them a starting place, and allows them to leverage the diagram as a way to think about the mathematics, in addition to a way to do the computation.

Next Steps

Choose one of the Number Talks to try in your classroom. When you are finished, record the patterns students notice in the problems and responses. Ask them why those patterns are happening and capture the ways in which they support their reasoning. What representations do they use and how do they show their brilliance?

Featured post

The 5 Practices: Looking at Differentiation Through a New Lens

Our district had seen a downhill trend in standardized test scores in mathematics. This forced us, as educators, to take an intentional look at our teaching practices.

The past few years have been an exciting time in math instruction. Research on brain plasticity and mindset have caused a shift in the idea of what it means to know and do mathematics. 

Continue reading “The 5 Practices: Looking at Differentiation Through a New Lens”
Featured post

Learning through Teaching

I was in New Orleans a couple of weeks ago visiting a school using IM 6–8 Math and was inspired by the efforts the school was making to implement problem-based instruction. I saw teachers at different stages on a learning curve with the instructional routines in the curriculum and realized how important it was to have a learning curve, and not a learning cliff, for teachers to grow into this way of teaching. We have tried to achieve this in many ways in our curriculum.

Continue reading “Learning through Teaching”
Featured post

Building a Math Community with IM K–5 Math

“I’m not sure this is working. Only five of my students are participating and commenting each day. The rest sit there and look at me.”

This was my conversation with our math coordinator after my first few days of teaching IM K–5 MathTM with my third graders. Those five students were having great conversations. However, my other students just sat there wide-eyed, silent, and staring blankly at their papers. I felt lost. Was this the best for my students? Could we survive a whole year of math like this? I wanted my students to love math and have a deeper understanding of mathematical concepts. How would this get them there? 

Continue reading “Building a Math Community with IM K–5 Math”
Featured post

Creating an Accessible Mathematical Community with IM K–5: the power of “yet” for students and adults

Does the perfect elementary math curriculum exist? Armed with a growth mindset and the Alpha IM K–5 curriculum, teachers in Ipswich Public Schools push their thinking to reach all mathematicians. 

I preach growth mindset daily. When my students say they can’t do something, they almost always add their own “…yet.” However, walking this walk as an elementary school teacher is another story. Creating, mastering, and modifying curricula to reach each and every student—in every content area—is a daunting expectation. We hold ourselves to near impossible standards. 

Continue reading “Creating an Accessible Mathematical Community with IM K–5: the power of “yet” for students and adults”
Featured post

Using Instructional Routines to Inspire Deep Thinking

We want students to think about math deeply. Creatively. Analytically. Instead, what often happens is that students race towards quick solutions. So what can we do to support this other kind of thinking in class—the slow, deep kind?

One way is through instructional routines like “Which One Doesn’t Belong” and “Notice and Wonder.” These routines give structure to time and interactions. Within the structure, there are opportunities to have time to think deeply and a predictable way to share and deepen thinking with partners and the whole class. 

Continue reading “Using Instructional Routines to Inspire Deep Thinking”
Featured post

Making Authentic Modeling Possible


The first thing you have to understand is that asking people to model with mathematics makes them mad. Not in all contexts, though! At a social gathering with a generally amiable and curious group of people, you might try floating a question like:

  • I wonder if graduates of more expensive universities tend to earn more in their careers?
  • Do you think the time it takes a pendulum to swing back and forth depends on how heavy it is?
  • What do you think is the most efficient way to get 2,000 calories a day?

Continue reading “Making Authentic Modeling Possible”
Featured post

Which Vertex is the Center of a Triangle?

I am sometimes asked what is the secret to the success of our curriculum, what is the special property that sets it apart from other curricula. That question is like the one in the title of this blog post, “Which vertex is the center of a triangle?” It doesn’t have an answer. None of the vertices is the center of a triangle; all three are equally necessary for it to exist. Similarly, all three vertices of the instructional triangle—students, teachers, and content—need equal attention in the work of teaching mathematics. And not only the vertices but the arrows between them, which “represent the dynamic process of interpretation and mutual adjustment that shapes student learning [and] instructional practice.”1 If there is something special about what we do in writing curriculum it is to pay equal attention to all parts of the instructional triangle. 

Continue reading “Which Vertex is the Center of a Triangle?”
Featured post

Updates to Supports for Students with Disabilities and English Language Learners in IM 6–8 Math

At Illustrative Mathematics we are committed to creating a world where learners know, use, and enjoy mathematics. We believe that every student can learn grade-level mathematics with the right opportunities and support. Our approach is to remove unnecessary barriers and provide teachers with options for additional support so that every student can engage in rigorous mathematical content. We’ve been busy this year working on some exciting enhancements to the teacher tools and supports to empower teachers to deliver instruction that meets the specialized needs of English learners and students with disabilities.

Continue reading “Updates to Supports for Students with Disabilities and English Language Learners in IM 6–8 Math”
Featured post

First Impressions: The First Units in IM K–5 Math

“I’ve learned that people will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel.”

― Maya Angelou 

When I think back to my 8th grade math class, I cannot recall the exact problems I struggled with or exact things the teacher said or did, but I can distinctly remember how I felt each day walking into that classroom: anxious. From the very first day of school, I struggled, and my feelings of failure and self-doubt only compounded as the year progressed. I just could not keep up. While many, many years have passed, and details have faded from my memory, I have never forgotten how badly I felt about myself as a learner of mathematics each day.  

Continue reading “First Impressions: The First Units in IM K–5 Math”
Featured post

Realizing the promise of open resources, part II

In my first post on the topic of realizing the promise of open educational resources, I described the IM Certified program. Our partners offer multiple versions, including a free online version and enhanced versions with different options for users. This is IM’s way of reaching teachers and students from a wide variety of districts who may be looking for those different options, while assuring that, as these versions evolve, they will stay true to the original design. However, by the terms of the CC BY license, anybody can use the curriculum with or without certification. This freedom further supports our mission to get these carefully crafted materials into the hands of as many students and teachers as possible.

Continue reading “Realizing the promise of open resources, part II”
Featured post

Up ↑